Sunset Beach Shelter Island Amenities photoSunset Beach Shelter Island Exterior photoSunset Beach Shelter Island Exterior photo
Book on our site
Up to 10% cheaper
than Booking.com
Check rooms and rates
From596US$ /night
Check-in
19Apr2026Select date
Check-out
20Apr2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Key details

About the Hotel

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11965
-
Nestled on an idyllic beach
Great
8.2
8.7
/10
3.8
3.5
/5

Accommodations

Sunset Beach offers a selection of spacious rooms and suites with captivating views of the water. Guests can choose from accommodations that include private balconies and direct access to the beach. Each room is equipped with premium linens and contemporary amenities to enhance the experience.

Dining and Drinks

The hotel's dining options include casual and fine dining experiences with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Guests can relax at the beachside bar, offering refreshing cocktails and light bites. The on-site restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, catering to diverse culinary preferences.

Location

Nestled along the shores of Shelter Island, Sunset Beach provides easy access to the mainland and local attractions. The hotel is close to scenic walking and biking trails, ideal for exploring the natural surroundings. Nearby options also include boat rentals for those looking to enjoy water sports.

Events and Activities

Sunset Beach offers event space for both intimate gatherings and larger occasions, accommodating a range of functions. The hotel organizes seasonal activities including beach volleyball and sunset bonfires. Guests can also enjoy scheduled entertainment throughout the year.

Family Amenities

The hotel provides family-friendly accommodations equipped with cribs and rollaway beds upon request. Children can enjoy various outdoor activities, ensuring a memorable experience. The property's beachfront location allows families to engage in safe swimming and sandcastle building.

Highlights

Location: Shores of Shelter Island

Rooms: Spacious rooms with private balconies

Dining: Beachside bar & on-site restaurant

Events: Event space for gatherings

Activities: Seasonal beach volleyball & bonfires

Must-do experiences

  • Stroll the beautiful Sunset Park for stunning bay views at sunset.
  • Indulge in fresh seafood at the Sunset Beach Grill, a local favorite.
  • Visit the Sheltered Island Historical Society Museum for local history.
  • Bike the scenic paths along Crescent Beach; rentals are nearby.
  • Check out the Farmers Market on Saturdays for local produce and crafts.
View all

Select your room type

Sunset Beach offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
King Room
2 persons
455 sq. feet 
1 King-size bed
Balcony
Air conditioning
Double Room Two Double Beds
2 persons
455 sq. feet 
2 Double beds
Balcony
Air conditioning
Deluxe King Room
2 persons
485 sq. feet 
1 King-size bed
Air conditioning

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Facilities

Sunset Beach offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

General

  • Wi-Fi
  • Smoke detectors

Dining

  • Restaurant
  • Bar/ Lounge area

Room features

  • Dressing area
  • Ironing facilities

Bathroom

  • Hair dryer

Media

  • Flat-screen TV
  • Direct dial telephone
  • CD player
  • AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

  • Carpeted floor
Show more

Sunset Beach Location

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11965
Map view
35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11965
Nearby
Sunset Beach
800 ft
Beach
Crescent Beach
1800 ft
Restaurants
The Pridwin Restaurant
3000 ft
81 Shore Road
Explore Shelter Island
Local Highlights
Top Attractions
Activities
Dining
Entertainment
Sunset Beach
3 minutes' walk
A beautiful beach spot known for stunning sunsets and relaxed vibes, perfect for sunbathing and seaside strolls.
Shelter Island Country Club
Shelter Island Country Club
10 minutes' walk
An inviting golf course offering beautiful greens. Ideal for golf enthusiasts and scenic views.
Shelter Island Tennis Club
10 minutes' walk
A friendly tennis club where players of all levels can enjoy matches in a welcoming environment.
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
4 minutes' drive
A historic estate offering farm tours, organic farming practices, and cultural events with unique educational experiences.
Kayaking at Crescent Beach
7 minutes' walk
Kayaking rentals available at Crescent Beach for a thrilling day on the water, suitable for beginners and experienced paddlers.
Yoga at the Beach
3 minutes' walk
Relaxing yoga classes offered on the beach, perfect for unwinding and enjoying the coastal ambiance.
The Pridwin Restaurant
The Pridwin Restaurant
11 minutes' walk
A fine dining option featuring local seafood and seasonal dishes, known for its picturesque views and elegant atmosphere.
Sunset Beach Restaurant
3 minutes' walk
Laid-back beachfront dining offering American fare, renowned for its grilled dishes and inviting terrace.
Shelter Island Film Festival
10 minutes' drive
An annual film festival celebrating independent filmmakers with screenings and special events throughout the week.
Live Music at The Pridwin
11 minutes' walk
Regular live music events featuring local artists in a vibrant setting, enjoyable for guests of all ages.
Getting around
City Centre
Shelter Island2 min  ·  400 ft
Airports
Long Island MacArthur (ISP)127 min  ·  52.5 mi
Republic (FRG)170 min  ·  70.2 mi
Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rate?
Get exlusive rates right now!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 16:00-23:59
Check-out
until 11 am
Guest Parking
Public parking is possible on site for free.
Internet
Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel for free.
Breakfast
A full breakfast is served and charges are applicable. 
Children & extra beds
One child: 0 - 2 years
Cot: FREE
Existing beds: FREE
One child: 3 - 17 years
Existing beds: FREE
Extra bed:
Children above
17 years or adults
:
Extra bed:
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Year renovated:
2010
Number of rooms:
20

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about Sunset Beach from previous guests about their experience.
Review score
Based on 14 verified reviews
8.7/10
Great
86%
Recommend
Guest reviews
based on 8 reviews
8.2/10
No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.
Open reviews
FAQs
About Sunset Beach
What are the check-in and check-out times at Sunset Beach?
Check-in time is 16:00 and check-out time is 11:00.
What beach amenities are available for guests at Sunset Beach?
Guests have exclusive access to a private beach.
How far is Sunset Beach from Long Island MacArthur Airport?
Sunset Beach is located 85 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport.
Are there nearby dining options when staying at Sunset Beach?
Nearby dining options include Shelter Island House, located 0.5 km away.
What room amenities are available at Sunset Beach?
Rooms are equipped with a flat-screen TV, climate control, iPod docking station, and DVD player.
Does Sunset Beach provide any wellness services?
Yoga sessions and in-room massages are available for guests.
What type of cuisine is served at the restaurant in Sunset Beach?
The on-site restaurant serves casual French cuisine.

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.
Check-in
19Apr2026Select date
Check-out
20Apr2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room