Shelter Island House * Award-Winning Inn Near Beach & Pool

Name: Shelter Island House, Shelter Island Heights
Address: 11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York State
Price range: US$569+
Rating: 9.3

57 photos

Shelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights Exterior photo

Shelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights Interior photo

Book on our site

up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights

Close to Sunset Beach

Perfect

9.3

/10

4.7

4.5

4-star boutique hotel with historic charm in Shelter Island Heights

Amenities

Shelter Island House offers a variety of complimentary amenities to enhance guest experiences. Guests can enjoy a seasonal outdoor pool, complimentary bicycles for island exploration, and beach essentials such as chairs, umbrellas, and towels. The hotel's on-site restaurant, Chez Marie, provides seasonal dishes crafted from local ingredients.

Rooms

The hotel features 11 uniquely decorated rooms, outfitted with spacious layouts, chic décor, and views of the surrounding gardens. Guests will find spa bathrooms equipped with oversized showers, soaking tubs, and luxurious C.O. Bigelow bath products. Each room includes thoughtful touches such as bathrobes and free in-room bottled water.

Location

Shelter Island House is conveniently located just one block from Crescent Beach, providing easy access to sun-soaked shores and aquatic activities. Nestled between Long Island's North and South Forks, the hotel offers proximity to local restaurants, shops, and outdoor adventures. Guests can arrive via a scenic ferry ride from Sag Harbor or Greenport.

Dining

On-site dining at Chez Marie allows guests to experience a range of small plates showcasing seasonal flavors. The Tavern at Shelter Island House serves a diverse menu with local favorites, offering both indoor and outdoor seating options. Guests can enjoy evening cocktails by the fire pit or relax during breakfast on the sunny deck.

Pet-Friendly Policy

Shelter Island House accommodates pets with prior approval, inviting guests to bring their furry companions along for the stay. Two pet-friendly rooms are available, accommodating dogs under 50 lbs, with a non-refundable deposit required. Nearby beaches provide ample opportunities for walks and outdoor play with pets.

Highlights

Location: One block from Crescent Beach

Rooms: 11 uniquely decorated rooms

Dining: Seasonal dishes at Chez Marie

Amenities: Complimentary bicycles & pool

Pet-Friendly: Accommodations for dogs under 50 lbs

Must-do experiences

Visit the historic Mashomack Preserve for stunning nature trails.
Taste the fresh seafood at the iconic Sunset Beach restaurant.
Explore the charming shops at Shelter Island's Greenport Village.
Catch a sunset at Crescent Beach for unforgettable views.
Don't miss the Shelter Island Historical Society for local insights.

Select your room type

Shelter Island House offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

King Suite
2 persons
39 sq. feet
1 King-size bed
Air conditioning
Bathtub
room details
Queen Room
2 persons
23 sq. feet
1 Double bed
Air conditioning
Bathtub
room details
Deluxe King Room
2 persons
25 sq. feet
1 King-size bed
Air conditioning
Bathtub
room details

Show all rooms

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

August 2026 - August 2027

Sun

Mon

Tue

Wed

Thu

Fri

Sat

August 2026

September 2026

October 2026

November 2026

December 2026

January 2027

February 2027

March 2027

April 2027

May 2027

June 2027

July 2027

Choose dates to see prices

Check-in/ Check-out

Facilities

Shelter Island House offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Facilities: Great

8.9/10Review score

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Parking
Safe deposit box
Pets allowed
Luggage storage

Sports & Fitness

Cycling

Services

Housekeeping

Dining

Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area
Picnic area/ Tables

Children

Cots
Board games

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Beach access
Beach umbrellas
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Garden area
Leisure/ TV room
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Sitting area
Garden furniture
Dining table

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Parquet floor

Dining Onsite

Shelter Island House invites guests to indulge in an exquisite dining experience at the Osprey Bar and Lounge. With an emphasis on American cuisine, diners can savor dishes crafted from seasonal fare by local farmers and fishermen while enjoying a charming ambiance.

Osprey Bar and Lounge
American
Ambiance
Cozy indoor space featuring a warm atmosphere with inviting seating arrangements, enhanced by a fireplace for chilly nights and outdoor dining by the sparkling swimming pool.
Key Offerings
Signature dishes prepared with a genuine love for cuisine by the chef, focusing on local and fresh ingredients. The menu adapts to seasonal offerings, allowing guests to experience the essence of the region.
Reservation
Recommended
Hours vary.

Shelter Island House Location

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights

Explore Shelter Island Heights

Explore Shelter Island

Crescent Beach

11 minutes' walk

Crescent Beach features beautiful sandy shores ideal for sunbathing and swimming, perfect for families and relaxation.

Dering Harbor Marina

20 minutes' walk

Dering Harbor Marina offers scenic views and excellent boating opportunities, making it a must-visit for water enthusiasts.

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

25 minutes' walk

Sylvester Manor showcases local history and agriculture, with seasonal tours and events that highlight its rich heritage.

Shelter Island Tennis Club

15 minutes' walk

Shelter Island Tennis Club provides an excellent space for players of all skill levels, offering lessons and social events.

Kayaking at Crescent Beach

11 minutes' walk

Kayaking offers an exhilarating experience on the water, with rental services available for guests seeking adventure.

Yoga Classes

15 minutes' walk

Local yoga studios provide classes in serene settings, perfect for relaxation and rejuvenation after a busy day.

Golfing at Shelter Island Country Club

7 minutes' walk

The country club features an 18-hole golf course set in a scenic landscape, ideal for both novices and seasoned golfers.

Eagle Deli

8 minutes' walk

Eagle Deli offers casual dining with favorite sandwiches and breakfast options, perfect for quick meals on the go.

The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor

20 minutes' walk

The Gatehouse serves farm-to-table dishes in a cozy atmosphere, focusing on fresh ingredients sourced from local farms.

Shelter Island Whale's Tail

25 minutes' walk

Families enjoy the local ice cream shop, known for its wide variety of flavors and outdoor seating, ideal for warm evenings.

Greenport Antique Carousel

10 minutes' drive

The antique carousel provides a nostalgic experience for all ages, featuring intricate designs and enchanting rides.

Getting around

City Centre
Shelter Island Heights 16 min · 4300 ft
Airports
Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 127 min · 52.3 mi
Republic (FRG) 169 min · 70.0 mi

Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rate?

Get exlusive rates right now!

Check Rates

Property information and rules

Check-in

from 15:00-22:00

Check-out

from 07:00-11:00

Guest Parking

Private parking is possible on site for free.

Internet

Wireless internet is available in public areas for free.

Children & extra beds

Maximum capacity of extra beds in a room is 1.

Pets

Pets are allowed on request.

Number of rooms:

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about Shelter Island House from previous guests about their experience.

Review score

Based on 9 verified reviews

8.9 /10

Great

90 %

Recommend

Cleanliness

9.1/10

Comfort

9.3/10

Facilities

8.9/10

Location

9.6/10

Staff

9.5/10

Value for money

8.9/10

No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.

Open reviews

Show more reviews

FAQs

About Shelter Island House

What are the check-in and check-out times at Shelter Island House?

Check-in is from 15:00 and check-out is by 11:00.

How far is Shelter Island House from Long Island MacArthur Airport?

The hotel is located 85 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport.

What dining options are available at Shelter Island House?

The hotel features an on-site restaurant and bar serving locally sourced cuisine.

Is parking available at Shelter Island House?

Free private parking is available on-site without the need for a reservation.

What amenities does Shelter Island House offer for guests?

Amenities include a seasonal outdoor pool, free Wi-Fi, a bar/lounge, and complimentary bicycles.

What recreational activities can guests enjoy at Shelter Island House?

Guests can enjoy cycling, swimming in the pool, and playing bocce or pétanque.

What room amenities are available at Shelter Island House?

Rooms feature air conditioning, flat-screen TVs, mini-fridges, and spa-inspired bathrooms.

How far is the nearest beach from Shelter Island House?

The hotel is situated just one block from Sunset Beach.

What nearby attractions can guests visit while staying at Shelter Island House?

Nearby attractions include Crescent Beach, the East End Seaport Museum, and Historic Haven's House.

Does Shelter Island House provide a breakfast option?

Guests can enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast served on the sunny deck.

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.

Blue Mountain Resort Village Suites

Blue Mountains, Canada

8.6195 reviews

92 USD/night

Camelback Resort

Tannersville, United States

7.649 reviews

161 USD/night

Bear Creek Mountain Resort

Breinigsville, United States

9.098 reviews

181 USD/night

Skytop Lodge

Skytop, United States

9.193 reviews

504 USD/night

The Dagny Boston

Boston, United States

8.9402 reviews

114 USD/night

Madison Resort Wildwood Crest

Wildwood Crest, United States

8.1

253 USD/night

The Watershed Norwalk

Norwalk, United States

8.3108 reviews

179 USD/night

Cloudland At Mclemore Resort Lookout Mountain, Curio By Hilton

Rising Fawn, United States

8.8

670 USD/night

Oglebay Resort

Wheeling, United States

8.373 reviews

199 USD/night

Caberfae Peaks Ski & Golf Resort

Harrietta, United States

9.050 reviews

121 USD/night

Wind Creek Bethlehem Casino & Resort

Bethlehem, United States

8.8143 reviews

121 USD/night

Adventures East Cottages And Campground

Baddeck, Canada

8.442 reviews

182 USD/night

Popular hotels all over the world

Find your perfect hotel stay today

7.8/106 reviews

Hotel Hotel Salcedo De Vigan

Vigan, Philippines

100 m from Calle Crisologo

View hotel

7.9/10176 reviews

O7 Nordeste Playa Hotel

Can Picafort (Mallorca), Spain

70 m from Can Picafort beach, All-inclusive, half-board, and B&B options

View hotel

8.9/10824 reviews

Hotel Cocoon Wien Westbahnhof - Ehemals Boutiquehotel Stadthalle Vienna

Vienna, Austria

First zero-energy city hotel in the world, Organic buffet breakfast with local products

View hotel

La Quinta Inn & Suites By Wyndham Mooresville Hotel

4 km from NASCAR Technical Institute, Microwave and mini-refrigerator in rooms

Hotel Hotel Sempione

15 min from main tourist attractions, 49 modern rooms

Emakhosini Hotel On East

5 km from Moses Mabhida Stadium, 42 rooms with Durban views

The Coco-Mat Athens Bc Athens Hotel

300 m from Akropolis Metro Station, Signature Coco-Mat Beds

Hotel Somewhere Inn Collingwood Boutique Hotel Collingwood

400 m from Collingwood Eddie Bush Memorial Arena, 1 km from Sunset Point Beach

The Alaiye Kleopatra Hotel Alanya Hotel

2 minute walk to Kleopatra Beach, Indoor and outdoor swimming pools